Thursday 18 July 2013

Dandelion - Wishes Brought to You - Review

“You play the story of 21 year old Hee-jung, a student who leaves home to study in far-away city of Busan. In many ways
she is a typical schoolgirl; she is a timid introverted girl who is very sensitive to what others say. However, she is also afflicted
by haunting childhood memories, and an an unrelinquished desire to succeed in life and surpass others. One day, something that
will change her busy lonely life happens. She comes home to find that a basket of three rabbits and two cats has mysteriously
been left in her bedroom. Soon, she will find out these are no ordinary animals ... They are in fact much more than that.

Why have these unusual animals been left to Hee-jung? What was the purpose behind this? Find the answer by playing
through this roller-coaster of emotions, full of surprises, deceit, and romantic adventures.”


Heejung... Well I can't really say I loved this protagonist. She has a lot of traits I've come to dislike in visual novels such as the typical dense characteristic. She isn't very bold either in my opinion and easily gets embarrassed by the thought of someone just holding her hand. She just sort of... gets on with her busy life even though she doesn't like it all because she's afraid her mother wont accept what she wants and she will be abandoned. That's perfectly understandable but it seems no matter what Heejung does her mother isn't happy about it so I don't see why she even bothers trying to be praised by her mother. I've had more of an 'indifferent' mother so that's probably why I can't quite understand her mindset but I'm sure some might. She does have some qualities I envy though: She's always hard working no matter what she's doing. I don't often come across people who put their everything into something, even if they dislike what they are doing. I generally think that's an incredible trait. But if nothing else, she seems realistic.

Jieun
The timid, apple obsessed Prince
I've read Jieun is the easiest guy to start with because he doesn't have a bad ending, so not really knowing how to play the game, I thought it'd be a good idea to follow this advise.
He's the timid little white rabbit. Apparently white is a sign that he's royalty, which I found rather interesting. In his route, he doesn't talk much to begin with and sticks close to Jihae. His favourite food is apples and he appears quite obsessed with them – always talking about them and wanting to eat them, but Heejung is told not to give him too many as sugar makes him aggressive, which she is reluctant to believe, and so was I. He's just so quiet and sweet! So after being told not to give him more than two a day, she let's him have seven – yes SEVEN apples (He sure doesn't have a problem getting him 5 a day at that rate) and quiet little Jieun starts acting as though he were drunk. He even smacks his head on the table. Geez. I didn't really see him as being as aggressive as I imagined when told about the sugar but yeah, he does change. Jieun starts yelling – ordering Heejung to give him more apples. It was kind of funny to see this! And that CG with his red cheeks was so adorable!! The main thing I liked about Jieun's route is how he changes over the year when he is with Heejung in a realistic way. He starts out the spoilt prince that he is, getting others to do even the most trivial thing for him such as straightening his ribbon. When going out on a date with him, he will even ask Heejung to open the door for him when they arrive back home, but as the story progresses, he starts to want to be more independent. He tries to help with the cooking, even though he's not very good at it and causes Heejung to take longer preparing dinner, I thought it was really sweet none-the-less! I didn't feel like he had on overly tragic past, it felt more like 'shit happens' but he feels guilty and his wish revolves around wanting to correct his mistake which is very mature of him.
Overall he has a nice route to begin with. His character is believable if not a little stereotypical in places and he's very adorable. Although having said this, I still felt at parts there was going to be some kind of BL with Jihae with how close their bond was... That might just be my mind in the gutter though! :3


Jiwoo
The huge tsundere
 Jiwoo was my second choice sheerly because I was sick of his attitude and I thought; “Screw you little bunny, let's see how that attitude changes after I catch you and make you mine”. Evidently... it's didn't change all that much.
Jiwoo is what you call the 'tsundere character' I suppose. He's loud and arrogant, often making himself out to be far more superior than everyone else – generally he's just a jerk. While pursuing Jiwoo he gives Heejung the nickname “Dumbo” and continued to call her stupid through most of the route even after they become a couple. Being the tsundere he is, even though he acts like a complete a-hole he actually only wants someone to reach out and understand him, which Heejung quickly realises - While he's sulking might I add... He sulks a lot actually, but it is kind of cute! :3
He's also complete obsessed with romance novels and old TV dramas as he tries to become some kind of romance guru. He seems to be the jealous type and is quick to jump to conclusions when he finds Heejung out with Jisoo. His 'tragic past' is sort of something that could quite easily happen in the real world... with a bit of a twist I suppose.
Overall I wasn't that keen on this route (Which is probably obvious in the little that I managed to wirite about Jiwoo) , I remember thinking things like: “I really want to punch this guy!” and “These two just don't seem right for each other at all!” but his ending was really something – I did enjoy it, I'll give him that. I have, however, seen a few people that seem to like Jiwoo a lot! Each to their own and all that!!


Jisoo
The kind but overly jealous black cat
He's my third because he's hawt!! Yep, that's right, that is all there is to my choice here! :3
The first thing I noticed about Jisoo's route is that he doesn't come across as being as stupid as he does in the other routes. He's actually very sweet and caring towards Heejung but he's also overly jealous and I mean OVERLY here as well as jumping to conclusions without a shred of proof. He constantly asks if Heejung has a boyfriend and if she is lying or not. It even goes as far as Jisoo saying she can't take other guys out with her (though I don't think she's the type to mess around anyway) or even think about other guys. He just comes off as 'two sides of the same coin' to me. The main thing I loved about Jisoo is how he's portrayed while talking about his little sister. He really does sound like he's a great older brother and that he loves her very much. Even though he's seen as being really cheerful (or madly jealous) throughout the game, he really shines during this part and the story about his past was rather heartbreaking – Not to the point where it made me choke up or made me tearful but it was still really touching! One of the other things to note about Jisoo is that his past, unlike the other two I've played to this point, doesn't explain his jealous personality but it does explain his need to protect Heejung. I might have missed something, or didn't interpret something I should have, but even at the end of his good ending I was still unsure of the reason for his jealous behaviour – Maybe there's something in his bad ending but I didn't get around to playing that yet. Nope, it still wasn't explained but holy hell was he scary on his bad route. I mean SERIOUSLY scary. I think he's been watching/playing Amnesia and got an idea from Toma or something. Drugging poor Heejung – crist. It was a pretty interesting experience though since I've, fortunately, never been in a situation like that before. And as an extra side note – Jisoo has the most CG's! 
Overall I honestly don't know what to think of Jisoo – There were just so many feels in his route. Every time I began to think: “Maybe he's just really worried about Heejung, it's sweet!” and started to overlook his jealousy and see only the kind side of him – BAM, he started acting jealous again and I was left thinking: “I really don't like this side of him!”. His good ending was really something though, I majorly choked up here. It was a great ending to a very emotional route. I think his character was written very well!



Jihae
The self-conscious gentleman
Well after using Jihae for Jisoo's bad route I felt kinda bad and I was interested as to what was hiding behind that gentleman exterior that I hadn't learned about from Jieun's route. Sadly... not much. Jihae was a complete gentleman throughout his route, his 'down side' was that he was very self-conscious about they way he looks. Heejung has a hard time keeping eye contact with him for the sole reason that he was so incredible beautiful and poor Jihae thought the reason she wouldn't look at him was because his appearance was displeasing. Even though he became a very successful model in a short space of time, he still seemed to believe looking at him was making Heejung uncomfortable for the wrong reason. Man, how many people can't relate to that one? I suppose that because I can relate so strongly to Jihae is the reason he quickly became my favourite! I couldn't help noticing that every time Heejung took Jihae out with her, he's always telling her to get some rest upon returning home. It eventually stopped and he started saying he'll cook tonight instead but I think because I was on the look out for hints that would lead me to his 'dark side' I was questioning everything. This game is totally messing with my head right now haha! I didn't really find out anything new about Jihae's past that wasn't already shared through Jieun's route, it was just more detailed. Talking about Jieun I actually thought Heejung would be sort of taking Jihae from him in an unknown sort of way here, and although that's kind of what happens, it's handled in such a way I didn't feel she was a bitch or anything. In other words it was done in a subtle but understandable way. Kind of like... Jieun hands him over, not necessarily happily but for Jihae's own good type way. Out of the four guys I've played so far, Jihae is the only one where Heejung's mother doesn't come storming into her life again to yell at her, instead, he's also the only one to try and break up with Heejung to make his disappearing easier on her – not necessarily the best thing to do but I could totally see where he was coming from! I'm also going to add as a side note that Heejung looks extremely beautiful in the last CG in this route!
 Overall like I already said, unless Jiyeon can beat Jihae, Jihae is my favourite guy. He's very caring and sensitive toward our protagonist and it's been nice to see a true gentleman in a visual novel – Lord knows it's hard to find one without an ulterior motive in the real world!! I can also imagine Jihae being last on most peoples list in order of playing as he does seem to be the quiet guy that just sits in the corner patiently waiting for his turn... Heck he even tells Jisoo something similar to that during the game.

Before I finish up with Jihae and move on to Jiyeon, I'm going to add that (until this point) Jihae's route seems to have the most mistakes in the text. His name was even misspelled at least twice!! Geez.

Jiyeon

And finally the little orange cat. Jiyeon might have been first on my list if I hadn't of played the demo which seems to push you in his direction. He acts cute and all but I didn't really like his sprite! I'm not entirely sure why and the fact that he can't pronounce a lot of words correctly isn't cute... It just isn't Jiyeon!! In fact his whole 'I'm an adorable little kitty – love me' thing didn't sit right with me at all. It may be some what 'cute' (for a lack of a better word) that his favourite colour is also his favourite food but seriously, if some free loader in my house was content with leaving orange peels all over my place for me to clean up when they have the luxury of getting their favourite food for free, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't continue to roll over and not only let him do as he pleases but encourage him! Bad Heejung!! There are several sides of Jiyeon shown in his route. His cute and cuddly side soon disappears after Heejung finds out that he's going out and lying to woman so that they will give him money and other things. He forcefully threatens Heejung, warning her to stay out of his business before leaving. He's actually quite terrifying here, but even after Heejung is abused she can't give up on him. I guess she's already in too deep but the fact that she mopes around constantly and acts like she wants to be thrown a pity party as well as feeling worthless all the time is not really what I like to see in a protagonist. I suppose it's realistic but still, it doesn't mean I have to like her right now! Those guys that can get into your head and make you feel completely worthless really are the worst! But having the strong desire to carry on and try to help him she does eventually get him back and you see yet another side of Jiyeon. It's similar to his first side – he's happy and playful but doesn't try to act cute any more. When Heejung tries to get him to stop manipulating other woman to get what he wants and to stop lying so much he agrees... a little to easily which again, didn't sit right with me. Considering he's a compulsive liar or sorts I didn't like how she could just trust his word like that! Love does strange things to people I suppose. I did actually take quite a liking to Jiyeon towards the end. He's sort of romantic in his own way. The scene with the Wizard before the credits felt a little rushed though. Usually there is dialogue back and forth between him and Heejung but for this route it was just him talking. Jiyeon also seems to be the only guy out of the five who is willing to throw away his chance at getting his wish by pushing away Heejung. I'm a little at a lose as to why he even agreed to be in the game...
Overall it's an interesting route, you get to see a lot of sides to Jiyeon. I personally think he's the most deceptive of the bunch. He's also the only one that doesn't have a scene for Christmas as well as being the sole guy to give her a gift during a scene, although it doesn't get put into your tiny little purse afterwards.

Wizard

The love crazed wizard
He may not really be an obtainable guy (even though I think it would have been interesting to see) but I think because he's an important part of the game (and hawt!!), I wanted to put a little bit about him. So he is of course the person who made the game involving Heejung, he does this because, apparently, he's madly in love with her after observing her in the human world. She can't see him of course, because she doesn't have a desperate wish and he gets tired of waiting. He's defiantly more of an obsessive stalker than anything else and I also thought it was a little crazy, but I suppose if you so desperately want something that is being dangled in front of your face but you can't have it, you're not going to stay sane forever. Once you complete the five guys routes there is a “Behind the story” option in the bonus tab within the extras option. You get to see more of his side of the story and why he's made the game. It's pretty interesting and at the end of it, there is a nice CG.
Overall though, I find it hard how he can justify himself as being “good”. I guess that granting peoples wishing is an incredible thing and if they are that desperate, the price of their memory doesn't look like a huge deal, but when he has to take away some ones memory to keep himself alive, the illusion of being good sort of fades away and you're left with what is necessary to survive!

  Heejae
Not actually an obtainable guy
Heejae may indeed not be romanceable but I wanted to write a little about him anyway. I'm sure anyone can tell just by looking at him that he doesn't fit in this game in that way. Even though I felt bad that he is like the definition of “friend zoned” I couldn't help but laugh at him most of the time. If you manage to get your stress level maxed (I only did this while the guys were animals, not after) he invites Heejung out for a drink and you get this pretty funny looking CG where he's pretty wasted. The creep is caught trying to invite himself into Heejung's house twice from what I've managed to find. I was also curious what would happen if I avoided increasing my points with all the guys before they turned human and this leads to a Heejae sort of ending which I pissed myself laughing at. Turns out the guys parents own a chicken restaurant and he's working hard delivering chickens... Man, the way he sounded so passionate about it, I couldn't help myself. There was a mixture of laughing and cringing on my part for this! Geez, I swear, you guys have to try this out. It really can't be missed, especially if you have a humour similar to my own!! He's gonna have to make that chicken pretty damn tasty if he hopes to provide for Heejung this way that's for sure!

Overall
There was one major thing that annoyed me with this game and that was the text. It was as if it didn't have a single proof-reader. There were so many typos, some words didn't have a space where they needed one (mainly in Jihae's route), some of the sentences were a little hard to understand because of unnecessary words and a lot of the time, the guys names were mixed up and misspelled, it was very off-putting to say the least and in some places, it really spoiled the mood for me! Considering you have to pay for this game, I did expect a little more here but even after saying that, I'm still grateful that it's in a language I can understand.
I knew off the bat that this was a stat raising game and I've never been that fond of them but this one just felt so much more drawn out then it needed to be. All that saving and loading also become tiresome fast. It made it quite difficult for me to finish this game in all honesty!
Other than that, the artwork is beautifully done. The story itself was okay, it's something I haven't quite played before, but I must say that if five guys suddenly turned up at my house with the selfish intention of trying to make me fall for them just so they can have a wish granted, I'd probably be pretty pissed to say the least no matter what that wish may have been.
I particularly loved how the guys were all so different from each other and although most of them I didn't end up liking, I still really enjoyed playing each route. Their personalities are so defined and I think they were all written really well! The way they interact with each other and the protagonist was believable and sometimes pretty comical. Their defining traits shone through strongly making them feel more like a person than something inside a game and the way they can sway your emotions was amazing: such as in Jisoo's route, I really did feel terrified for Heejung, which isn't an emotion I normally get to feel in a visual novel and in Jihae's, my heart really did go out for him for most of his route!
Another thing that took my fancy was the option to go out with a guy on the weekend (assuming they were home). There were so many options and I really liked that fact that each guy responds to the weather depending on what time of the year you go out. Such as if you go to the beach when it's cold and you come across a girl in a bikini they will pass a comment on it. This again makes the game more realistic in my opinion!
Ah, yeah, one more thing, and I'm not sure if I liked this or not but you couldn't look through the CG's of a guy until you finished his route. It certainly helped motivate me to complete the game but at the same time, I can't help thinking that that feature was only put in place because of the tiresome stat building mechanics.

I'd like to just say that I'd be happy to recommend this game and leave it at that but it's not going to happen. I'd personally only recommend this game to people have don't have a problem with the stat building mechanics in these games and if you have a lot of patience. If you're still on the fence about it, there is a demo out along with the full version of the game!

And finally, I'll leave you with this cute/funny picture!

7 comments:

  1. Hello! I really like your review, it seems like you put some effort into making it! :3 And what interested me even more was that it's not really positive, like most of the other Dandelion reviews.:D I thought I was the only one who didn't find it all that great. Anyway, what do you think about the endings, though? :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey, thanks for the compliment. It's always nice to hear what people think of my reviews since I'm still new to it and trying to improve. To be completely honest, I felt most of the endings to be lacking. Most of the time Heejung doesn't re-meet the guys and they just hinted she does. It leaves the story wide open but I guess the company want their readers to make up their own minds on what happens. I didn't really like most of the endings. If I had to choose - I'd say my favourite was Jieun because it was so different to the rest and Jihae because that one was just sweet <3. That's the closest to 'Happily ever after' you're going to find in this VN in my opinion. Jiwoo seemed like a bit of an ass in his (Even though that kind of is his trade mark characteristic). From my view on it, he left Heejung for what appeared to be at least a few weeks to 'become a better man' or 'find himself' even though she was trying to deal with memory loss to such an extent - I don't really remember the exact details heh.
    I've seem a few people who were wondering if there would be a sequel to the game because they too thought the end was lacking overall.
    It didn't bother me that the game didn't end with them getting married or whatever that is sort of traditional for this type of game but something a little more would have made it better - again only in my opinion.
    Even though it was stated many times that it is nearly impossible for Heejung to regain her memories, I think it would still be rather interesting to see how she would react if she did somehow remember... Although her character kind of makes me think she'd just sort of... be fine with it for a lack of a better term heh.
    Heh, I think I sort of rambled on there and went slightly off-topic but in short; the endings were very lacking. It was interesting to see what the guys looked like while they were no longer animals and I think if the company made like an epilogue it would have wrapped the game up better.

    Well I hope that answered your question and thanks for taking the time to read my review and comment! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I completely agree with you.(But not about the favourites, my favourite is Jiwoo, then Jihae XD)Thanks!

      Delete
  3. Why do I always get Heejae's bad end? orz

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ME TOO!!!
      Even when my stress is 0, I still get the bad ending in the art room with Heejae. I've never managed to get even one heart with the guys. I think my game is bugged :( :(

      Delete
  4. If you're interested Cheritz translated/made another game called Nameless which had the Wizard in. He's the same person in both and I would argue he was actually hotter in nameless, due to the style. He's only in it at some points though. Maybe look him up online. Someone must have took a screen shot.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Ah, finally, a review I can agree with. I've been so puzzled about the hype around dandelion. Frankly, I thought it was terribly average bordering on irritating. I suppose the character's personalities put me off, the men are precisely the types I would profile as 'do not date, gurl you gonna die,' and the mc is sort of pathetic. Maybe I'm being too harsh, but well, the game made me want to bash my head against the wall and punch the characters. Mind you, kudos with the art and details. And I played it years ago, maybe I should try again with less lofty expectations...

    ReplyDelete